Skip to content Skip to navigation

Article: Spatiotemporal variation in completeness of the early cynodont fossil record and its implications for mammalian evolutionary history

Palaeontology - Vol. 64 - Cover Image
Publication: Palaeontology
Volume: 64
Part: 2
Publication Date: March 2021
Page(s): 307 333
Author(s): Grace L. Varnham, Philip D. Mannion, and Christian F. Kammerer
Addition Information

How to Cite

VARNHAM, G.L., MANNION, P.D., KAMMERER, C.F. 2021. . Palaeontology, 64, 2, 307-333. DOI: /doi/10.1111/pala.12524

Author Information

  • Grace L. Varnham - Department of Earth Sciences University College London Gower Place London WC1E 6BT UK
  • Philip D. Mannion - Department of Earth Sciences University College London Gower Place London WC1E 6BT UK
  • Christian F. Kammerer - North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences 11 West Jones Street Raleigh NC 27601 USA

Publication History

  • Issue published online: 04 March 2021
  • Manuscript Accepted: 10 December 2020
  • Manuscript Received: 02 September 2020

Funded By

Royal Society Research Fellows Enhancement Award. Grant Number: RGF/EA/180318
Royal Society University Research Fellowship. Grant Number: UF160216

Online Version Hosted By

Wiley Online Library
Get Article: Wiley Online Library [Pay-to-View Access] |


Mammals are the only surviving group of Cynodontia, a synapsid clade that first appeared in the fossil record in the late Permian, ~260 million years ago. Using three metrics that capture skeletal completeness, we quantify the quality of the early cynodont fossil record in time and space to evaluate the impact of sampling and preservational biases on our understanding of the group's evolutionary history. There is no consistent global sampling signal for early cynodonts. Completeness of the cynodont fossil record increases across the Permian–Triassic boundary, peaking in the Early to early Late Triassic. This peak is dominated by specimens from southern Africa and South America, where a highly seasonal climate probably favoured preservation. Completeness is generally lower thereafter, correlating with a shift from a Gondwanan to a predominantly Laurasian fossil record. Phylogenetic and stratigraphic congruence in early cynodonts is high, although their fossil record exhibits less skeletal completeness overall than other tetrapod clades, including the contemporaneous anomodont synapsids. This discrepancy could be due to differences in the diagnosability of their fossils, especially for small‐bodied species. Establishing the timing and assembly of derived (‘mammalian’) anatomical features in Cynodontia is obscured by sampling. Two of the major nodes at which acquisition of mammalian features is concentrated (Cynodontia and Mammaliamorpha) suffer from lengthy intervals of poor sampling before becoming abundant parts of tetrapod faunas. Low completeness in these intervals limits our ability to determine when certain ‘key’ mammalian characteristics evolved, or to identify the selective pressures that might have driven their origins.

PalAss Go! URL: | Twitter: Share on Twitter | Facebook: Share on Facebook | Google+: Share on Google+